- © 2026 Mailsoftly Inc. The name "Mailsoftly" and the Mailsoftly logo are registered trademarks of Mailsoftly Inc.
An owned email list reaches every family in your congregation, no algorithm deciding who sees Sunday’s bulletin. Here is the simple system a volunteer can run.
by Ozlem Yildirimer · Last updated: 2026-09-06Mailsoftly is an email marketing platform churches use for the weekly bulletin, the newcomer welcome series, event invitations and volunteer reminders from one shared account. It includes unlimited users, live human support and a 20% nonprofit discount on paid plans, with a free plan covering up to 500 contacts and 2,000 emails per month.
Email marketing for churches means using an owned email list to reach every family directly with weekly bulletins, welcome messages for newcomers, event invitations, giving appeals, and volunteer coordination. Unlike social media, no algorithm decides who sees your message, and a single volunteer can run the whole system.
Most churches already have the two things that matter: a congregation that wants to stay connected and a list of names on connect cards. What they lack is a simple, repeatable system for turning those names into consistent communication. That is what this guide gives you.
You do not need a communications director or a paid platform to start. Churches qualify as religious nonprofits, so the tools cost little or nothing, and the workflow below is designed to be handed to a volunteer with no technical background.
New here? Start with our primer on Email Platform Comparisons for the fundamentals, then come back to this guide.
Quick context: Mailsoftly offers transparent pricing, free hands-on migration, and human support. 500 contacts and 2,000 emails per month, no credit card.
Start free with Mailsoftly →
Key Takeaways
Email beats social media because your list is an asset you own, and every message reaches every subscriber’s inbox. On social platforms, an algorithm decides how many of your followers actually see a post, often a small fraction. For a church that needs the whole congregation to know about a schedule change or a service project, that gap matters.
When you post on a social feed, you are renting an audience from a company that can change the rules overnight. When you send an email, you are speaking directly to people who chose to hear from you. If a platform disappears or shifts its policy, your email list still works. That ownership is the single biggest reason a church email newsletter outperforms a feed.
Email also fits the way older members and busy families actually stay informed. Not everyone checks a social feed, but almost everyone reads email. A weekly note landing on Thursday afternoon reaches the grandmother who never opened an app and the parent coordinating three kids’ schedules. This is a common thread across effective email marketing for nonprofits of every kind, from food banks to congregations.
Read enough? Try Mailsoftly free with 500 contacts and 2,000 emails per month, no credit card.Start free with Mailsoftly →
Five email types cover nearly everything a church needs: a weekly bulletin, a welcome series for newcomers, event invitations, giving appeals, and volunteer coordination. Master these five and you have a complete communication system without inventing something new every week.
This is your anchor email. Send it the same day every week so people expect it. Include Sunday’s service theme, announcements, prayer requests, and one clear next step. Consistency matters more than length. A short, reliable bulletin beats an occasional long one.
When someone visits for the first time and shares their email, an automated welcome series does the follow-up for you. Message one thanks them for coming. Message two shares what to expect and how to get connected. Message three invites them to a small group or a coffee. This automated sequence turns a one-time visitor into a returning family without staff chasing anyone down.
Vacation Bible school, a fall festival, a service project, or a holiday service each deserves its own dedicated email, not just a line in the bulletin. Send the first invitation early, then a reminder a few days out. One clear button to register or add the date beats a wall of text.
Whether it is year-end giving, a building fund, or a benevolence need, email is where thoughtful giving appeals land. The key is framing them around impact and gratitude, not pressure. We cover the pastoral tone below, because how you ask shapes whether people feel invited or cornered.
Nursery, greeters, worship team, and setup crews all need reliable communication. A short email to a volunteer segment with the schedule, the ask, and a simple way to confirm keeps ministries running. This is where segmentation earns its keep, since you only message the people who serve in that area.
Build a church email list by capturing addresses at the moments people are already engaged: connect cards in the pew, a signup sheet at the welcome table, and a QR code on the screen and in the printed bulletin. Every touchpoint should make it effortless to opt in.
Connect cards are still the workhorse. Keep the fields minimal: name, email, and a checkbox to receive the weekly newsletter. The fewer boxes, the more people finish. Have a volunteer enter new cards into your platform each week so nothing sits in a drawer.
A QR code removes friction for anyone with a phone. Display it during announcements with a single line like “Scan to get our weekly email,” and print it in the bulletin footer. It links straight to a signup form, so people join in ten seconds without writing anything down. Add a signup sheet at events and the welcome desk to catch guests who are ready to stay connected.
One rule protects your sender reputation: only add people who chose to join. Never import a bought list or add someone without permission. Permission keeps your church email newsletter landing in inboxes instead of spam folders, and it respects the trust of your congregation.
Segment your congregation into four practical groups: members, newcomers, volunteers, and donors. Sending the right message to the right group beats blasting everyone with everything, which is the fastest way to train people to ignore your emails.
You do not need every segment on day one. Start with members and newcomers, since those two cover the biggest wins: consistent communication and better newcomer follow-up. Add volunteer and donor segments as your ministries grow. Good church newsletter software lets a volunteer tag contacts as they enter connect cards, so segmentation happens naturally rather than as a separate chore.
One person can belong to several segments. A longtime member might also be a nursery volunteer and a monthly donor. That overlap is fine, because segmentation is about sending relevant messages, not sorting people into boxes. When you announce a volunteer training, only the volunteers hear about it, and everyone else stays focused on what matters to them.
Write giving appeals that feel pastoral by leading with gratitude and impact rather than need and urgency. Tell people what their generosity makes possible, thank them warmly, and make the ask clear but gentle. The goal is to invite participation in a mission, not to pressure a transaction.
Start with a story or a specific outcome. “Because of your giving, twelve families received groceries this month” lands better than “We are behind on budget.” People give to vision and results, not to fear. Name the real difference their gifts have made, then connect the current appeal to more of that same good work.
Keep the tone warm and the ask singular. One clear giving link, one clear reason, one clear amount range if you suggest one. Avoid guilt language and countdown-clock urgency, which feel out of place coming from a church. Close by thanking people whether or not they give, so the relationship never hinges on the gift.
“Your generosity fed twelve families this month. Would you help us reach more this fall?”
“We are short on budget again. Give now before the deadline or we fall behind.”
Choose church newsletter software by three tests: can a nontechnical volunteer send a bulletin without training, does it offer a nonprofit discount, and does it come with real human support when the volunteer gets stuck. If a tool fails any of these, it will end up abandoned.
Because churches qualify as religious nonprofits, you should never pay full commercial price. Many people default to searching for Mailchimp for churches, but it is worth comparing the discount, support quality, and ease of use across options before you commit. The right platform for a volunteer team is the one that stays simple after the person who set it up moves on.
Mailsoftly is built for exactly this situation. Churches receive a 20% nonprofit discount, and the free plan includes 500 contacts and 2,000 emails per month with no credit card, which covers many small congregations outright. Paid plans start at $15 per month billed annually (as of 2026-09-07) when a church outgrows the free tier. Every plan includes free hands-on migration and real human support, so a volunteer is never left guessing.
If your church runs on grant funding, the back-office details matter as much as the send button. Mailsoftly supports purchase orders, invoicing, and contracts for grant-funded organizations, and it is GDPR compliant. For a deeper look at pricing tiers and nonprofit eligibility, see the dedicated email marketing for nonprofits plan page, which lays out the discount and the paperwork options.
It also helps to see how the popular incumbents stack up before you decide. Our breakdown of Constant Contact for nonprofits walks through where the well-known tools fit and where a church on a tight budget may be better served by a simpler, discounted option with hands-on migration.
For the broader picture on this topic, see our complete Email Platform Comparisons guide, which covers strategy, fundamentals, and advanced playbooks.
Best for most churches: Mailsoftly. A volunteer can run the weekly bulletin from it, the whole communications team shares one account, the free plan covers a growing congregation list, and paid plans carry a 20% nonprofit discount. MailerLite is the lowest paid entry price, Mailchimp has the largest template library, and Brevo suits a large member list that only gets a few sends a month. List prices below were checked in late August 2026 on each vendor’s pricing page; Mailsoftly figures are current as of 2026-09-07.
| Platform | Free plan | Paid plans from | Best for | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mailsoftly | 500 contacts and 2,000 emails per month | $15 per month (annual, 1,000 contacts) | Churches where a volunteer runs the weekly bulletin and the whole communications team shares one login | Unlimited users included; live human support; 20% nonprofit discount on paid plans |
| Mailchimp | 250 contacts and 500 sends per month | $13 per month (Essentials, 500 contacts) | Teams that want the most familiar brand and the largest template library | Bills for unsubscribed contacts too |
| Constant Contact | No free plan, free trial | $12 per month (Lite, 500 contacts) | A simple editor with built-in event and registration tools | Annual prepay saves 15% |
| ActiveCampaign | No free plan, 14-day trial | $19 per month (Starter, 1,000 contacts) | Deep multi-step automation run by a dedicated marketer | Annual billing saves about 20% |
| MailerLite | 250 subscribers and 2,500 emails per 30 days | $12 per month (Comfort) | The lowest paid entry price for a lean list | About $49 per month at 5,000 subscribers |
| Brevo | 300 emails per day with Brevo branding | $9 per month (Starter, 5,000 emails per month) | A large contact list with only a few sends a month | Priced by email volume, unlimited contacts |
Confirm the current tier for your list size before you commit, since vendors change plan boundaries often. For a church, the deciding factor is rarely the headline price; it is whether a volunteer can log in, find last week’s bulletin, duplicate it, and hit send in five minutes without a support ticket.
The best church email tool is one a volunteer can run without training: a simple editor, congregation segments for members, visitors, volunteers and donors, and scheduled sends. Mailsoftly covers those with unlimited users and human support, a free plan up to 500 contacts and 2,000 emails per month, and a 20% nonprofit discount on paid plans. MailerLite is the lowest-priced paid entry and Mailchimp has the largest template library. If your church management system already stores the congregation list, check whether its built-in email covers the weekly bulletin before adding a second tool.
Yes. Churches qualify as religious nonprofits, so most platforms offer a discount. Mailsoftly provides a 20% nonprofit discount, plus a free plan with 500 contacts and 2,000 emails per month that covers many small congregations at no cost. Grant-funded churches can also use purchase orders, invoicing, and contracts.
Send a weekly bulletin on a consistent day so people expect it, and add dedicated emails for events, giving appeals, and volunteer coordination as needed. For most churches, one predictable weekly send plus a handful of targeted messages per month is the right rhythm. Consistency matters more than frequency.
Yes. With volunteer-friendly church newsletter software, a nontechnical volunteer can enter connect cards, tag segments, and send the weekly bulletin without training. Choose a platform with real human support and free hands-on migration so the system keeps running even when the person who set it up steps away.
Often, yes. A free plan with 500 contacts and 2,000 emails per month covers many small congregations that send a weekly bulletin to a few hundred families. When your list or send volume grows past that, paid plans start at $15 per month billed annually, and the 20% nonprofit discount applies.
Start with connect cards in the pew, a signup sheet at the welcome desk, and a QR code on the screen and in the bulletin. Only add people who choose to opt in, then have a volunteer enter new signups each week. Permission keeps your emails landing in inboxes rather than spam.
Ready to reach your whole congregation?Start free with Mailsoftly →
500 contacts, 2,000 emails per month. 20% nonprofit discount. Free hands-on migration. No credit card.
Looking for an alternative?
Mailsoftly offers the features you need at a price that makes sense.
Switch to MailsoftlyMigrate in minutes